Examples?

Quoting CubbyUps:

Quote:
Are profiles that use 'Double Feature', is that to be entered in the Title section of the Edition section?

In this case, "Double Feature" suggests that we're talking about the title of a box set and not a movie, so it makes sense to me that it's part of the title and not an edition.  If you really feel the need to put this in the edition field then that should go in the child profiles that you create for the individual films.

---------------

I say it depends. Is this the one you're talking about?



If so, I would say that neither "Double Feature" nor "2 Movies" have any informational value, so I would leave them out altogether.

In the cases that AndyEN mentions I am  more ambivalent. I can see his point, but personally I would probably prefer the two individual movie titles in the title field and the named double feature in the edition field.

Quoting AiAustria:

Quote:
Examples?

"10"/Tarzan the Ape Man: Romance Double Feature
Ace Ventura: Deluxe Double Feature
Airplane! / Airplane II: The Sequel: Blu-ray Double Feature
Alien Nation / Enemy Mine: Double Feature 2-DVD Set
The Beast From 20,000 Fathoms / Them!: SCI-FI Double Feature
Bloodsport / Timecop: Action Double Feature
Captain America / Captain America II: Death Too Soon: Action-Packed Double Feature
Eddie and The Cruisers/Eddie and The Cruisers II Eddie Lives: Totally Awesome 80s Double Feature
Flipper/Flipper's New Adventure: Family Double Feature
Ghostbusters 1 & 2: Double Feature Gift Set
Strange Invaders / Invaders From Mars: Midnite Movies Double Feature

I think that's enough to give the idea.

Now I do have some profiles where 'Double Feature' is attached to a single film.
Such as:
Attack of the Puppet People: Midnite Movies Double Feature
Beach Blanket Bingo: MGM Movie Legends Double Feature
The Legend of Zorro: Double Feature
The Skulls: Double Feature

So when a single film is a part of some sort of 'Double Feature' I think it is fine to put some variant of Double Feature in the Edition section since it distinguishes it from other stand alone profiles of the same film.

So in conclusion, as I understand the rules.
Box Set titles should use what is on the cover to reflect what it is. Be it a collection of several films such as Star Wars films or just two films as in a double feature.

Individual titles of box sets should have such in the edition section to distinguish that profile from other profiles that may be contained in other box sets or individually.

yes I believe it depends as well.