Quote:
Quoting Mad Rockatansky:

Quote:
Year of the Gun (1991) as Carlo Scandiuzzi ADR Voices invalid

For the record: whether that's an invalid credit is very much up for debate. They're certainly being contributed and accepted into the database on a regular basis.

Quote:
Quoting Mad Rockatansky:

Quote:
Tell me, how should I consider it...
Valid or Invalid?

You'll get a different answer depending on who you ask. My opinion on this never changed: what I want most of all, is to be consistent. So if we're including the same group of people when they're labelled "Additional Voices" or "Voice Cast", then I'll track them if they're called "ADR Cast" or "ADR Voices" as well. Either they're all out, or they're all in, but I'll treat the exact same people providing the exact same job exactly the same way. So if you ask me, I would consider this a valid credit. Personally, these credits are more interesting to me than local dubbing voices - something Ken did actually publicly sign off on as being valid entries. And if we can track those, then it seems ridiculous to not include these voice actors, too. The bottom line is that once you've seen a dozen "ADR Cast" groups, of which the word "Cast" makes it pretty hard to claim that they aren't part of the cast, it becomes a lot harder to ignore roughly the same group of people in a different film when they're under an "ADR Voices" header. They're the same people, providing the same job. I refuse to include "ADR Cast" and then leave out "ADR Voices" - either we track both, or neither. So I choose to track both, but others will most certainly disagree. And as so often, Invelos refuses to make a decision...

Quote:
If you include ADR voices as valid Cast credits you should consider the inclusion of foley crew in cast as well.