Quoting Woola:

Quote:
Rho: I peresume that you too have read the rules, but based on youtr comment i could be wrong.

Skip

Yes, specially the part about outtakes does definitely not match for 'deleted scenes' labeled as 'outtakes' in the menu:

Quote:
Footage, generally mistakes, captured during filming, generally humorous. Occasionally, outtakes are scripted (e.g. animated outtakes).

And don't tell me, that the deleted scenes or the main film are not data on the DVD itself and only the menus are. That would be very strange.

Quoting lmoelleb:

Quote:
Quoting Dr. Killpatient:

Quote:
If it walks like a duck...

... then it is a witch - burn it!

Runs!  Hides!  No burning the witch!

On topic - I agree with the majority here.  Many things can be mislabeled.  Just the other day my co-worker filed an X-Box game as a DVD.  That did not make it a DVD, only a mislabeled X-Box game.

We must follow content over labels, for only content gives accurate data.

You people really are an arrogant lot that believes you know more than the people who make the disc. but the surefeur thinks he can correct anything, typos, whatever. This database is eaded for the scarp heap, but not with my help, you will drag there all by yourselfves. You do NOT know more than thepeople who make the fim or the disc, you have NO IDEA why they do what they or whether it is a mistake or not. What a bunch of

Skip

Quoting Woola:

Quote:
You people really are an arrogant lot that believes you know more than the people who make the disc. but the surefeur thinks he can correct anything, typos, whatever. This database is eaded for the scarp heap, but not with my help, you will drag there all by yourselfves. You do NOT know more than thepeople who make the fim or the disc, you have NO IDEA why they do what they or whether it is a mistake or not. What a bunch of

Skip

I'm just glad that this place isn't lacking in common sense

Quoting surfeur51:

Quote:
Quoting Woola:

Quote:
You people really are an arrogant lot that believes you know more than the people who make the disc. but the surefeur thinks he can correct anything, typos, whatever.

I haven't even posted on this topic... Just an attack to spew hatred. 

Wow.

Quoting Forget_the_Rest:

Quote:
Quoting Alien Redrum:

Quote:
So in essence, Skip, you are saying that in a hypothetical situation, if the cover says French subtitles, the disc says French subtitles, but there are no French subtitles on the disc, only Spanish (which aren't listed anywhere), it is wrong to correct the profile by removing the French subtitles and adding Spanish?

That's effectively what I said earlier in the thread. Unless I missed it, I don't think I got a response.

That is true. 

I suspect there won't be a (logical) answer, either.

I think we've reached a general consensus at the very least. Everyone (except one) agrees so I think that's how we should treat the situation personally.

Using the menu text is just fine, but digging deeper isn't wrong and if there is an error, then what the feature actually is supersedes what is written in the menus. I would just stress to those contributing such errors to point it out in the notes so future contributers don't accidentally erase it by changing it to what is shown in the menus. 

And if we were to do as woola says than the The Lawnmower Man Collection DVD UPC 794043-132247 would be wrong in the data base too. The cover says the both films are widescreen 16x9 2.4:1 and you go to watch the films there is no widescreen just full screen.... So should I have contributed it as widescreen? The people who make the film or the disc, say it's widescreen. They never make mistakes, they are perfect, like woola.