Kluge:

You have only documented that Amazon has your cover on file.The problem is that your undercover was also the Original rellease cover. However,  I will give you...this first in wins, if it is your cover that is already on file then the new Contribution should be voted NO and declined.There is no guarantee that Amazon nor any other source follows our Rules, their image may simply be that of the most recent one.But based on what I have gleaned from your comments in at least one case (store) theyreceived the same UPC with a special cove, which later became the general release. So,  I would say your cover should NOT be replaced, based upon your remarks.

Quoting TheDarkKnight:

Quote:
Now we can start to argue what is covered under this and what is not but why?

People here want strict application of rules. Nothing about those stickers, so nothing to interpret. Rules say to scan cover or slip case, not stickers. Nobody can choose just what he wants to take in rules, even if the result is stupid, which is not the case here.

Quoting bigdaddyhorse:

Quote:

There is one big difference though, those paper covers are under the shrinkwrap and often glued to the steelbooks (with that same removable/reusable glue). They also contain specs and info, not just the same picture and feel like part of the package. Over the shrinkwrap makes it feel like it should be thrown out, and if this wasn't lenticular I probably would toss it.

It shouldn't be called a slipcover, I'd say faceplate sums it up (and was used on the Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake 2-disc dvd already). This is the second of these I recall on a new release in the US though, both by Fox. "Fox-plate" or face-plate should be the term, and clickable option like slipcover.

Kluge never said it was over the shrink wrap, he said it was on the plastic sheet of the cover which I would consider under the shrink wrap basically glued onto the keep case and I would keep it and also scan it for my collection. To call it a faceplate sounds good to me.
I agree that the ones we find on the back of steelbooks contain important information but it doesn't change the fact that they are not covered by the rules either but we use them because they have this information on it.

@surfeur51  Do you need to bring this attitude of yours to every thread here?

Quoting Astrakan:

Quote:
Nice. 16-page thread averted. 

 

Quoting Ken Cole:

Quote:
In this case the sticker is similar to a slip cover and so if it is the first release, that's the correct cover.  This is similar to many US versions I've seen where the back of the set is a flimsy piece of paper with a glob of temporary glue holding it on.  Those have the UPC, overview, info, etc. and are the correct back scan in those cases.  I personally dislike them as they have a habit of getting lost around my house.

Hopefully VirusPil adds this to Collected Statements from Invelos on contribution discussions

Quote:
... until we enable multi-cover support.

   
WANT!

cya, Mithi

Quoting Ken Cole:

Quote:
This is similar to many US versions I've seen where the back of the set is a flimsy piece of paper with a glob of temporary glue holding it on.  Those have the UPC, overview, info, etc. and are the correct back scan in those cases.

Hi, I'm the contributor of the profile.

Just one problem... it is NOT the back of the case! So no UPC, no overview, no info on it. You are referring to a very different case, like Fox boxsets that have nothing under the paper.

Furthermore the sticker can easily be removed and almost all did it 'cause it is a mini-poster with humorous slogan "Vietato ai non-umani". The actual cover is what I scanned with the real italian movie slogan "Vietato agli umani". It reverse completely the sense of the slogan. The original one says "Forbidden to humans" as a sign made by aliens, the second one says "Forbidden to non-humans".
Normally no one likes stickers over the cover and who wants to scan a clean cover pull it out the case and scan it.

Quoting CyberPaul:

Quote:


Furthermore the sticker can easily be removed and almost all did it 'cause it is a mini-poster with humorous slogan "Vietato ai non-umani". The actual cover is what I scanned with the real italian movie slogan "Vietato agli umani". It reverse completely the sense of the slogan. The original one says "Forbidden to humans" as a sign made by aliens, the second one says "Forbidden to non-humans".
Normally no one likes stickers over the cover and who wants to scan a clean cover pull it out the case and scan it.

Sorry but I'm afraid to remove the sticker, because it's well glued on the plastic.
Furthermore if we should connsider it as a slip cover, that is the cover that we have to contribute.